Flipper end-of-stroke (EOS) switches
Here's the thing about EOS switches in a modern pinball machine: they're optional.
To be very clear, EOS switches are only optional if the software is written to not use them. You can't just walk up to an existing game and cut the wires to the EOS switches or you'll probably burn up your coils. (I say "probably" because some games will detect that the EOS switch wasn't hit when it should have been and cut the power anyway.)
If you wanted to program a game without EOS switches, you could do that. The way you'd do that is to flip from "power" to "hold" mode after a predefined time (like 30ms), rather than waiting for an EOS switch to be engaged.
Why would you want to use the "pulse timing" method versus the "EOS switch" method for the flipper power stroke? There are a few reasons:
- You can control the "strength" of the flippers in software, rather than with hardware. This means you can fine tuning the flipper feel for your game without having to swap coils or adjust voltages.
- You can allow operators to change flipper strength via a service menu item, compensating for mismatched coils, coil age, machine slope, etc. However, this could also be implemented using PWMed pulses with full stroke and EOS cut-off.
- Your software can change the strength as part of a game feature. (For example, Wizard of Oz has a "weak flippers" mode which makes the shots harder.) This can also be implemented with EOS by reducing the pulse time below the EOS (tpyical) cut-off time.
Having said this, there's still a reason you might want to use the EOS switches today----the EOS switch can be used to detect if a fast-moving ball has hit the flipper so hard that it broke through the hold power and caused the flipper bat to fall down. The idea is you'd use the EOS switch to reactivate the power winding (or to reapply full power if you're using the pulse method) until the EOS switch is activated again, and then you'd go back to holding the coil.
Whether you actually want to do this is a matter of opinion. Finding the proper strength for your hold power----especially if you're using the pulse method----is a balance between applying enough power to keep the flipper bat up without using so much power that your coil overheats. Some argue that if you get this balance right, your hold power should be enough to stand up to a fast ball hitting an upheld flipper. The other thing to consider with this is that even if a fast-moving ball does knock the flipper bat down, there's no agreement on whether automatically re-applying full power to raise the bat is the right thing to do. Some have argued that that's confusing to the player, and that if the flipper bat does fall down when the player is not expecting it, that the player should choose to re-engage it by releasing and reapplying the flipper button.
Even if you don't use EOS switches for action purposes in your game, chances are your flipper mechanisms have them. Assuming you have enough switch inputs available, we like the idea of wiring up your EOS switches anyway and just audit logging whether an EOS switch is deactivated while its associated flipper button is still active. Doing so means you capture the number of times a ball inadvertently moves a flipper bat, and you can make power adjustments to your hold phase accordingly. It also lets the machine know if the flippers are broken.
How does the machine know when the flipper is "up"?
You might notice that both of the options for not burning up the flipper coils when they're held up require that the machine "knows" when the coil is up in order to switch over to hold mode. So how exactly does a machine know this?
Many flippers in pinball machines today have an "end of stroke" (or "EOS") switch for each flipper. This switch was located under the playfield near the flipper coil, and it is physically activated by the flipper mechanism once it has rotated fully into the "up" position. In the old days (like in EM machines), the flipper coils all used the dual winding (i.e. "Option 1" from above) approach, and the EOS switch was a normally-closed switch connected in series with the flipper cabinet button which activated the power winding. So when the flipper button was pressed, both the power and hold windings were activated, and then when the flipper was all the way up it would open the EOS switch, cutting off power to the power winding. The hold winding remains energized until the player releases the flipper button.
When EOS switches are used in modern machines, they're typically connected into into the game like any other switch, so the CPU can process the EOS activation and disable the power winding or start pulsing the power.
Option 2: The flipper has one winding, and the game lowers the power once the flipper is up
The other type of flipper uses a normal coil with just a single winding. When the flipper button is pressed, the machine fires the flipper coil with normal full power. Then once the flipper makes it to the "up" position, the game starts pulsing the power really quickly. (So fast that it doesn't move the flipper back down, but with enough "spaces" between the pulses that the coil doesn't burn up.)
Then when the flipper button is released, the power is cut to the altogether. In case you're wondering why the machine pulses the power, it's because the pinball machine doesn't have the ability to actually change the voltage and current that is supplied to the coil. That's fine, though, because what actually causes a coil to burn is the heat generated from the current flowing through it. So a coil which is pulsed on then off every millisecond would only have a "duty cycle" of 50%, thereby generating far less heat and not burning up. (The 1ms on / 1ms off is just an example for this illustration. In a real machine it might be 1 on / 10 off, or 2/18, or 1/6---the exact pulse ratio depends on the coil type and the amount of voltage used.)
This single-winding coil is less common. Stern used to do it though in their current SPIKE system they've moved back to dual-wound flippers.
Design Decision 2: Pulse timings or EOS switch to indicate "up" position?
Next you have to figure out how you're machine will know when to switch to the low power hold mode. (How it switches depends on Design Decision 1, where it either cuts off the high power winding, or switches over from the solid pulse to the quick on/off modulated pulses.) If you use pulse timings then it switches over after a certain number of milliseconds. If you use the EOS switch then it activates full power until the EOS switch is activated. Our view is that using the EOS switch to switch over to low-power hold mode is far less flexible than configuring specific initial pulse times. We like that this allows game designers and operators to precisely configure flipper power, and certainly this is a much more modern approach than physically swapping out flipper coils to increase or decrease power. Then again, if you're old school and want to fire that flipper with full power until that EOS switch is activated, fine, go for it.
Design Decision 3: Will you use EOS switches to notify the game that a ball has "broken through" the hold?
Modern machines use pulse-width modulation (PWM) to keep flipper bats up because most coils will instantly burst into flames if you enable them at 48V which are typically used in today's machines. PWM uses a so called duty-cycle which determines how much energy moves into the flippers. More energy strictly results in more power but that energy also turns into heat. Unfortunately, the resistance in copper wires in the coil increases with the temperature and, consequently, the less current and energy will flow through the coil. As a result the coil will become weaker of time when it heats up. Since we do not know the temperature in software this cannot easily be compensated as runtime (and the coil would probably become even hotter and burn if we would try).
Finding the right spot where the coil is strong enough, knockdowns do not happen and the temperature stays low enough is not generally easy. Parts age over time, environment temperature differs between location and even the voltage might fluctuate. We have seen overheating of coils in some machines by newer manufacturers.
So what can we do about this? We can detect when the EOS switch opens while the flipper button is active and repulse the flipper coil. Ideally, this should happen inside the pinball hardware but this is not supported by all hardware platform in MPF. For all remaining platforms, we mitigate this in software in MPF. This introduces a few milliseconds of delay but it should be fast enough that the player does not notice it.
This is how you can enable it in MPF:
#! switches: #! s_flipper_single: #! number: 1 #! s_flipper_single_eos: #! number: 2 #! s_flipper_dual_wound: #! number: 3 #! s_flipper_dual_wound_eos: #! number: 4 #! coils: #! c_flipper_single_main: #! number: 0 #! c_flipper_dual_wound_main: #! number: 2 #! c_flipper_dual_wound_hold: #! number: 3 #! allow_enable: true flippers: single_wound_flipper: main_coil: c_flipper_single_main activation_switch: s_flipper_single eos_switch: s_flipper_single_eos use_eos: true repulse_on_eos_open: true eos_active_ms_before_repulse: 500 dual_wound_flipper: main_coil: c_flipper_dual_wound_main hold_coil: c_flipper_dual_wound_hold activation_switch: s_flipper_dual_wound eos_switch: s_flipper_dual_wound_eos use_eos: true repulse_on_eos_open: true eos_active_ms_before_repulse: 500
To prevent repeated activations MPF will wait
eos_active_ms_before_repulse ms before a repulse can happen. There are
certain races between hardware rules and this mechanism which MPF tries
to handle (but we might have missed cases - let us know if you find any
rough edges or weird behavior with this).
In general, this should allow you to reduce PWM power by a lot and instead use repulses in the rare case of knockdowns. This should work with all platforms and will use hardware rules if your platform supports them.
Something missing or wrong? You can fix it!
This website is edited by people like you! Is something wrong or missing? Is something out of date, or can you explain it better?
Please help us! You can fix it yourself and be an official "open source" contributor!
It's easy! See our Beginner's guide to editing the docs.
Page navigation via the keyboard: < >
You can navigate this site via the keyboard. There are two modes:
General navigation, when search is not focused:
- F , S , / : open search dialog
- P , , : go to previous page
- N , . : go to next page
While using the search function:
- Down , Up : select next / previous result
- Esc , Tab : close search
- Enter : go to highlighted page in the results